合肥專(zhuan)利律師按：專利(li)授(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)后(hou)(hou)，根據專利(li)法13條之規定，專利(li)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)人(ren)有權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)向專利(li)臨時保護期(qi)內被控(kong)侵權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)主(zhu)張報酬。但無權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)禁止專利(li)臨時保護期(qi)限(xian)內的(de)所制造的(de)被控(kong)侵權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)品，在專利(li)授(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)公告后(hou)(hou)的(de)銷售與使用(yong)。同時，專利(li)授(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)后(hou)(hou)，被控(kong)侵權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)人(ren)對(dui)上述(shu)期(qi)限(xian)內的(de)產(chan)(chan)品提供的(de)售后(hou)(hou)服(fu)務，也(ye)不應屬于專利(li)侵權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)行為。

合肥陳軍(jun)知(zhi)識產權律師(shi)團隊

2015年(nian)1月2日

申請(qing)再審人（一審被告、二(er)審上(shang)訴人）：深圳市坑梓自來(lai)水有(you)限公(gong)司。

 被(bei)(bei)申請人（一(yi)審原(yuan)告、二審被(bei)(bei)上訴人）：深圳市斯瑞(rui)曼精(jing)細化(hua)工有限(xian)公司。

被申請(qing)人(ren)（一審被告(gao)、二審上訴人(ren)）：深圳市康泰藍水處理設備有(you)限(xian)公司(si)。

申(shen)請再審(shen)人(ren)(ren)深(shen)圳市坑(keng)(keng)梓自(zi)來水(shui)有(you)限公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)（以(yi)下(xia)簡(jian)稱(cheng)坑(keng)(keng)梓自(zi)來水(shui)公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)）因與被申(shen)請人(ren)(ren)深(shen)圳市斯瑞(rui)(rui)曼精細化工有(you)限公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)（以(yi)下(xia)簡(jian)稱(cheng)斯瑞(rui)(rui)曼公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)）、深(shen)圳市康泰(tai)(tai)藍水(shui)處理(li)設備有(you)限公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)（以(yi)下(xia)簡(jian)稱(cheng)康泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)）侵犯發明(ming)專利權糾紛一案(an)(an)，不(bu)服(fu)廣(guang)東省(sheng)高級人(ren)(ren)民(min)法(fa)院(yuan)(yuan)（2010）粵高法(fa)民(min)三終字第444號民(min)事(shi)判決，向本(ben)(ben)院(yuan)(yuan)申(shen)請再審(shen)。本(ben)(ben)院(yuan)(yuan)于2011年5月4日作出（2011）民(min)申(shen)字第179號民(min)事(shi)裁(cai)定，提審(shen)本(ben)(ben)案(an)(an)。本(ben)(ben)院(yuan)(yuan)依法(fa)組成合(he)議庭，公(gong)(gong)開(kai)開(kai)庭審(shen)理(li)了本(ben)(ben)案(an)(an)。坑(keng)(keng)梓自(zi)來水(shui)公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)的(de)委(wei)托(tuo)代理(li)人(ren)(ren)梅珊、林吉磷，斯瑞(rui)(rui)曼公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)的(de)委(wei)托(tuo)代理(li)人(ren)(ren)潘中毅到庭參加訴訟，康泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)經本(ben)(ben)院(yuan)(yuan)合(he)法(fa)傳(chuan)喚，無(wu)正當(dang)理(li)由未(wei)到庭。本(ben)(ben)案(an)(an)現已審(shen)理(li)終結(jie)。

2009年3月16日，一審原告斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)起(qi)訴至廣東省深圳市中級人民法院稱：其(qi)擁有(you)專(zhuan)利號為(wei)ZL***.0、名稱為(wei)“制備高(gao)純度二氧化(hua)氯的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)設(she)備”的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)發(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利（以下(xia)簡稱涉(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利），康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)生產、銷(xiao)售和(he)坑(keng)梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)使用的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)二氧化(hua)氯生產投加設(she)備落入涉(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利保護范(fan)圍。請(qing)(qing)求(qiu)(qiu)判令(ling)(ling)：1.康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)立即(ji)(ji)停(ting)(ting)(ting)止侵犯涉(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利權(quan)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)生產、銷(xiao)售行(xing)為(wei)。2.坑(keng)梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)立即(ji)(ji)停(ting)(ting)(ting)止侵犯涉(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利權(quan)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)使用行(xing)為(wei)。3.康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)共同賠償斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)因(yin)此造成的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)經濟損失(shi)人民幣叁拾萬元。4.康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)承擔(dan)(dan)斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)維護自(zi)(zi)身利益所支(zhi)出(chu)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)合理費用。5.康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)承擔(dan)(dan)本(ben)案(an)(an)(an)(an)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)所有(you)訴訟(song)費用。在一審庭審中，斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)當庭請(qing)(qing)求(qiu)(qiu)增加判令(ling)(ling)康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)立即(ji)(ji)停(ting)(ting)(ting)止侵犯涉(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利權(quan)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)許諾銷(xiao)售行(xing)為(wei)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)訴訟(song)請(qing)(qing)求(qiu)(qiu)，并當庭明確(que)本(ben)案(an)(an)(an)(an)中的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)被訴侵權(quan)產品的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)發(fa)(fa)生器型號是KTL - FSQ10000L，計(ji)量器型號分別(bie)是KTL - LSJ280L、KTL- LSNJ280L；明確(que)在本(ben)案(an)(an)(an)(an)中要求(qiu)(qiu)判令(ling)(ling)康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)賠償其(qi)所支(zhi)出(chu)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)證費等計(ji)500元。

被(bei)告(gao)(gao)康泰藍公司(si)(si)答(da)辯稱：1.原告(gao)(gao)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)產品在其申請(qing)日前已(yi)(yi)經(jing)(jing)公開銷售，并且只是現(xian)有(you)技術(shu)簡單(dan)拼湊(cou)，缺(que)乏專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)性，斯(si)瑞曼(man)公司(si)(si)行為屬于濫用專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)權(quan)，請(qing)求(qiu)中(zhong)止(zhi)審(shen)理本(ben)案。2.涉(she)案發明(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)權(quan)利(li)要(yao)求(qiu)1缺(que)乏必要(yao)技術(shu)特征，不(bu)能作(zuo)為比對的基礎。3.被(bei)告(gao)(gao)產品不(bu)構成(cheng)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)。4.被(bei)告(gao)(gao)產品所(suo)使用的為專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)申請(qing)前就已(yi)(yi)經(jing)(jing)存(cun)在的已(yi)(yi)有(you)技術(shu)，不(bu)構成(cheng)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)。

被(bei)告(gao)坑梓自來水(shui)公司答辯稱(cheng)，其屬于善意第三人，請求(qiu)免除賠償責(ze)任(ren)。

廣東省深圳市中級人民法院(yuan)一審查明(ming)：

（一）關于斯瑞曼公司(si)請求保護的涉案發明專利

斯瑞曼公司于2006年1月19日向國家知識產權局申請了名稱為“制備高純度二氧化氯的方法和設備”的發明專利，該專利于2006年7月19日公開，2009年1月21日授權公告，授權的(de)發明名稱(cheng)為“制備高純度(du)二氧(yang)化(hua)氯的(de)設備”，專利權人為斯瑞曼(man)公司(si)，專利號(hao)為***.0。該專利最近一次年(nian)費繳納時間為2008年(nian)11月28日。

斯瑞曼公司明確其在本案中以涉案發明專利(li)權(quan)利(li)要求1作(zuo)為其(qi)專利(li)權(quan)保護范圍。所述權利(li)要求1為：一(yi)種制備高純度二(er)氧化氯的(de)(de)設(she)備，其特征(zheng)在于(yu)：具有通(tong)過兩路管(guan)(guan)(guan)(guan)道順序(xu)連接的(de)(de)第(di)一(yi)液體計(ji)量(liang)(liang)槽(cao)（1）和(he)第(di)一(yi)計(ji)量(liang)(liang)泵(beng)（3）、第(di)二(er)液體計(ji)量(liang)(liang)槽(cao)（2）和(he)第(di)二(er)計(ji)量(liang)(liang)泵(beng)（4），該兩路接文(wen)(wen)氏(shi)管(guan)(guan)(guan)(guan)加(jia)(jia)料(liao)器(qi)(qi)（8），然后至(zhi)氣液分(fen)離器(qi)(qi)（12）；文(wen)(wen)氏(shi)管(guan)(guan)(guan)(guan)加(jia)(jia)料(liao)器(qi)(qi)（8）的(de)(de)進口端(duan)與(yu)第(di)一(yi)空氣進口（7）連接；第(di)一(yi)計(ji)量(liang)(liang)泵(beng)（3）和(he)第(di)二(er)計(ji)量(liang)(liang)泵(beng)（4）與(yu)文(wen)(wen)氏(shi)管(guan)(guan)(guan)(guan)加(jia)(jia)料(liao)器(qi)(qi)（8）之(zhi)間的(de)(de)管(guan)(guan)(guan)(guan)道上分(fen)別設(she)有第(di)一(yi)加(jia)(jia)熱(re)器(qi)(qi)（5）和(he)第(di)二(er)加(jia)(jia)熱(re)器(qi)(qi)（6）。

（二）關于康泰藍(lan)公司(si)的被訴(su)許諾銷(xiao)售行(xing)為

深圳(zhen)市公(gong)證(zheng)(zheng)處(chu)（2009）深證(zheng)(zheng)字第4204號公(gong)證(zheng)(zheng)書、深圳(zhen)市公(gong)證(zheng)(zheng)處(chu)（2009）深證(zheng)(zheng)字第28582號公(gong)證(zheng)(zheng)書顯示，康泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)公(gong)司在(zai)其網站公(gong)司產(chan)品“康泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)二氧化(hua)(hua)氯制備投加工藝(yi)簡介”中(zhong)宣稱，“化(hua)(hua)學制備二氧化(hua)(hua)氯，根據不(bu)同的(de)原料(liao)(liao)和(he)還原劑，有(you)多種不(bu)同的(de)生(sheng)產(chan)工藝(yi)。我公(gong)司采用的(de)是以氯酸鈉和(he)硫酸為原料(liao)(liao)，過氧化(hua)(hua)氫為還原劑的(de)生(sheng)產(chan)工藝(yi)，即R11法。該工藝(yi)的(de)生(sheng)產(chan)設備是我公(gong)司自主研發的(de)產(chan)品，并獲得國家專(zhuan)利(li)局的(de)專(zhuan)利(li)證(zheng)(zheng)書（專(zhuan)利(li)號為***.4）。”

2005年(nian)12月(yue)20日，項耀明(ming)向國(guo)家知(zhi)識產(chan)權(quan)(quan)(quan)局(ju)申請了名(ming)稱(cheng)為(wei)“一(yi)種(zhong)二氧化氯消毒(du)裝置”的實用新型專利(li)，于2007年(nian)6月(yue)20日獲得授權(quan)(quan)(quan)，專利(li)權(quan)(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)為(wei)項耀明(ming)，共同專利(li)權(quan)(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)為(wei)焦立國(guo)，專利(li)號(hao)為(wei)ZL***.4。2009年(nian)2月(yue)23日，國(guo)家知(zhi)識產(chan)權(quan)(quan)(quan)局(ju)發(fa)出“手續(xu)合格通知(zhi)書”，稱(cheng)根據云(yun)南(nan)省高級(ji)人(ren)(ren)民法院（2008）云(yun)高民三終字第(di)101號(hao)民事判(pan)決，項耀明(ming)、焦立國(guo)將 ZL***.4號(hao)專利(li)轉(zhuan)讓給南(nan)京國(guo)友(you)環保科(ke)技有(you)限公司的行(xing)為(wei)無效(xiao)。準(zhun)予申請人(ren)(ren)（專利(li)權(quan)(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)）由南(nan)京國(guo)友(you)環保科(ke)技有(you)限公司變更為(wei)斯瑞曼公司。

（三）關于被(bei)訴侵權(quan)產(chan)品(pin)

2009年4月20日，一審法院(yuan)應斯(si)瑞曼公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)申請，來(lai)(lai)到坑梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)，對該(gai)公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)正在(zai)使(shi)用(yong)中的由(you)(you)康泰藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)生(sheng)產的二氧化氯(lv)生(sheng)產投加設備進(jin)行(xing)證據保全。庭審過程中，康泰藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)確認坑梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)的二氧化氯(lv)發生(sheng)制備器系(xi)由(you)(you)其銷售(shou)給坑梓(zi)自(zi)(zi)來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)。

根(gen)據康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)公司(si)所提(ti)交的《購銷(xiao)合同(tong)(tong)》以及(ji)(ji)稅(shui)務(wu)機關代(dai)開統一發票記賬聯，2008年10月20日，坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)公司(si)與康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)公司(si)簽訂《購銷(xiao)合同(tong)(tong)》一份，坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)公司(si)向康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)公司(si)購買KTL - FSQ10000L康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)二氧化氯發生器1套(tao)，價(jia)款為(wei)(wei)26萬元。康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)公司(si)已于2008年12月30日就上述(shu)產品(pin)銷(xiao)售款要(yao)求(qiu)稅(shui)務(wu)機關代(dai)開統一發票。在上述(shu)《購銷(xiao)合同(tong)(tong)》中，約定坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)公司(si)分(fen)期向康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)公司(si)支付設備款項(xiang)，康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)(lan)公司(si)為(wei)(wei)坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)公司(si)提(ti)供安裝、調試、維修、保養等技術支持及(ji)(ji)售后服務(wu)。

康泰藍公司確認（2009）深中法民三初字第92號、（2009）深中法民三初字第93號、（2009）深中法民三初字第95號案件其銷售給相關水廠的設備與本案設備為同一型號的相同產品，其技術特征完全一致。訴訟過程中，斯瑞曼公司、康泰藍公司、坑梓自來水公司均同意選擇深圳市橫崗自來水有限公司下屬荷坳水廠被訴侵權設備作技術比對。2009年11月17日，在一審法院組織下，斯瑞曼公司、康泰藍公司、坑梓自來水公司來到現場對被訴侵權設備進行了察看及比對并各自提交了相應的書面意見。

（四）關(guan)于被訴侵權(quan)產品與涉案發明(ming)專利權(quan)利要求1的比對

將被訴侵權產(chan)品與涉案發(fa)明專利權利要(yao)求1進行比對(dui)。被訴侵權產(chan)品是一(yi)種制備高純(chun)度二(er)(er)氧化氯(lv)的設備，具有通過(guo)兩路管道順序連(lian)接的第(di)(di)(di)一(yi)液體(ti)計(ji)(ji)量槽和(he)第(di)(di)(di)一(yi)計(ji)(ji)量泵(beng)、第(di)(di)(di)二(er)(er)液體(ti)計(ji)(ji)量槽和(he)第(di)(di)(di)二(er)(er)計(ji)(ji)量泵(beng)，第(di)(di)(di)一(yi)空氣(qi)進口與“噴射(she)反(fan)應器(qi)”進口端相(xiang)連(lian)。對(dui)此，雙(shuang)方當事(shi)人均不持(chi)異議。

庭審(shen)中，康泰藍公司聲稱(cheng)被訴侵(qin)權(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)不具有“文(wen)氏管加(jia)料(liao)器(qi)(qi)”，相關(guan)部件為“噴射反應器(qi)(qi)”；不具有“第(di)一加(jia)熱器(qi)(qi)和(he)第(di)二(er)加(jia)熱器(qi)(qi)”，相關(guan)部件是“原(yuan)料(liao)加(jia)溫瓶”；被訴侵(qin)權(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)的(de)“原(yuan)料(liao)加(jia)溫瓶”沒(mei)有連接在“計量泵”和(he)“文(wen)氏管加(jia)熱器(qi)(qi)”之(zhi)間的(de)管道上；被訴侵(qin)權(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)沒(mei)有“氣液分離器(qi)(qi)”。

經過2009年11月17日對被訴(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)現場(chang)勘察、比對后，康泰(tai)藍公司提(ti)交技術(shu)(shu)比對說明(ming)，認為被訴(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)與(yu)涉(she)(she)(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)的(de)主(zhu)要(yao)(yao)區(qu)別(bie)(bie)在于結構及(ji)連接關系(xi)上(shang)的(de)區(qu)別(bie)(bie)以(yi)及(ji)設備(bei)(bei)實(shi)質操作(zuo)(zuo)流(liu)程(cheng)(cheng)的(de)區(qu)別(bie)(bie)。被訴(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)沒有“氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離器(qi)”，被訴(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)“噴射反應(ying)(ying)器(qi)”之后出(chu)來的(de)管(guan)(guan)路(lu)只有一(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)以(yi)及(ji)備(bei)(bei)份管(guan)(guan)路(lu)一(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)，該管(guan)(guan)路(lu)用于傳送氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液混合(he)物直至反應(ying)(ying)器(qi)，管(guan)(guan)路(lu)及(ji)備(bei)(bei)份管(guan)(guan)路(lu)均向(xiang)下(xia)伸入到反應(ying)(ying)器(qi)內液面以(yi)下(xia)。涉(she)(she)(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)技術(shu)(shu)方案(an)(an)中的(de)文氏管(guan)(guan)與(yu)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離器(qi)相連，出(chu)來的(de)管(guan)(guan)路(lu)分(fen)(fen)兩條(tiao)(tiao)，一(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)體管(guan)(guan)路(lu)向(xiang)上(shang)用于排(pai)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)，一(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)液體管(guan)(guan)路(lu)向(xiang)下(xia)與(yu)反應(ying)(ying)器(qi)相連；被訴(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)工作(zuo)(zuo)流(liu)程(cheng)(cheng)為：原料—混合(he)—主(zhu)反應(ying)(ying)器(qi)。按(an)照涉(she)(she)(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)技術(shu)(shu)方案(an)(an)（權(quan)(quan)利(li)(li)要(yao)(yao)求1），其(qi)工作(zuo)(zuo)流(liu)程(cheng)(cheng)為：原料—混合(he)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離（氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離后，氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)體從氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)體管(guan)(guan)路(lu)排(pai)出(chu)）—液體—主(zhu)反應(ying)(ying)器(qi)。因此(ci)，康泰(tai)藍公司認為，被訴(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)缺乏涉(she)(she)(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)利(li)(li)要(yao)(yao)求1中的(de)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離器(qi)這一(yi)必要(yao)(yao)技術(shu)(shu)特征。

關于“文(wen)(wen)氏管加(jia)(jia)料器(qi)(qi)”與“噴射反(fan)應器(qi)(qi)”。一審法院認為(wei)，根據(ju)涉案發明(ming)專(zhuan)利(li)說明(ming)書第4頁第6行-第10行的(de)記(ji)載，以(yi)及二者在制(zhi)備二氧化氯(lv)的(de)設備中(zhong)所(suo)處的(de)位置及與其(qi)他裝置的(de)連接關系(xi)可(ke)知，“文(wen)(wen)氏管加(jia)(jia)料器(qi)(qi)”與“噴射反(fan)應器(qi)(qi)”均(jun)是(shi)對(dui)稀硫酸(suan)、氯(lv)化鈉和過氧化氫的(de)混(hun)合(he)液以(yi)及熱空氣進行混(hun)合(he)反(fan)應生成二氧化氯(lv)的(de)裝置。并(bing)且，康泰藍(lan)公司所(suo)提交的(de)其(qi)產品使(shi)用說明(ming)書中(zhong)也明(ming)確提及文(wen)(wen)氏管。可(ke)見，“文(wen)(wen)氏管加(jia)(jia)料器(qi)(qi)”和“噴射反(fan)應器(qi)(qi)”只是(shi)對(dui)同(tong)一技術(shu)特征的(de)不(bu)同(tong)文(wen)(wen)字(zi)表述，其(qi)實(shi)質(zhi)是(shi)同(tong)一個裝置。

關于“第一(yi)(yi)加(jia)(jia)(jia)熱(re)(re)器(qi)(qi)(qi)和(he)(he)第二(er)加(jia)(jia)(jia)熱(re)(re)器(qi)(qi)(qi)”與“原料加(jia)(jia)(jia)溫(wen)瓶(ping)”。一(yi)(yi)審(shen)法院認(ren)為(wei)，根(gen)據涉(she)案發明(ming)專(zhuan)利(li)說明(ming)書第4頁(ye)第6行(xing)-第8行(xing)記載的(de)(de)(de)內容，“第一(yi)(yi)加(jia)(jia)(jia)熱(re)(re)器(qi)(qi)(qi)和(he)(he)第二(er)加(jia)(jia)(jia)熱(re)(re)器(qi)(qi)(qi)”是(shi)分別對稀硫酸、氯(lv)化(hua)鈉和(he)(he)過氧化(hua)氫的(de)(de)(de)混合液進行(xing)加(jia)(jia)(jia)熱(re)(re)的(de)(de)(de)裝置(zhi)(zhi)，而被訴侵(qin)權(quan)產品的(de)(de)(de)“原料加(jia)(jia)(jia)溫(wen)瓶(ping)”也是(shi)對原料（即(ji)稀硫酸、氯(lv)化(hua)鈉和(he)(he)過氧化(hua)氫的(de)(de)(de)混合液）進行(xing)加(jia)(jia)(jia)溫(wen)（加(jia)(jia)(jia)熱(re)(re)）的(de)(de)(de)裝置(zhi)(zhi)。所以，“原料加(jia)(jia)(jia)溫(wen)瓶(ping)”與“第一(yi)(yi)加(jia)(jia)(jia)熱(re)(re)器(qi)(qi)(qi)和(he)(he)第二(er)加(jia)(jia)(jia)熱(re)(re)器(qi)(qi)(qi)”同(tong)(tong)樣只是(shi)對同(tong)(tong)一(yi)(yi)技(ji)術特征的(de)(de)(de)不同(tong)(tong)文字表述(shu)，其實質(zhi)是(shi)同(tong)(tong)一(yi)(yi)個(ge)裝置(zhi)(zhi)。

關于“原(yuan)料加(jia)溫瓶(ping)(ping)”（“加(jia)熱(re)(re)器”）的位置(zhi)。一審法院認為，從(cong)證據保全所(suo)獲照片以及(ji)現(xian)場察看可以看出，“原(yuan)料加(jia)溫瓶(ping)(ping)”（“加(jia)熱(re)(re)器”）的位置(zhi)明顯是在“計量泵(beng)”和“文(wen)氏管加(jia)熱(re)(re)器”之間的管道上。

關于(yu)(yu)“氣(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)器(qi)”。一審法(fa)院認為，首(shou)先，從技(ji)術原理來(lai)看(kan)，被(bei)訴(su)侵權產(chan)(chan)品(pin)必(bi)須連接(jie)氣(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)裝置對反應(ying)后(hou)的(de)氣(qi)體和液體進行分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)。其次(ci)，從康泰藍(lan)(lan)公(gong)司相關技(ji)術資料來(lai)看(kan)，被(bei)訴(su)侵權產(chan)(chan)品(pin)使用了氣(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)法(fa)。第三，從現場勘察被(bei)訴(su)侵權產(chan)(chan)品(pin)實物來(lai)看(kan)，被(bei)訴(su)侵權產(chan)(chan)品(pin)“噴(pen)射(she)反應(ying)器(qi)”之(zhi)(zhi)后(hou)連接(jie)的(de)“三通管(guan)道(dao)”與涉案發明專利中的(de)“氣(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)器(qi)”功能、作(zuo)用并無不(bu)(bu)同。康泰藍(lan)(lan)公(gong)司關于(yu)(yu)第一細管(guan)用于(yu)(yu)傳送(song)氣(qi)液混合物，第二(er)細管(guan)為備份管(guan)路(lu)的(de)辯解，既(ji)沒(mei)(mei)有相應(ying)實物證據支持，也有悖于(yu)(yu)技(ji)術常理，同時(shi)，與康泰藍(lan)(lan)公(gong)司產(chan)(chan)品(pin)培訓資料以及(ji)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)使用說明等(deng)也不(bu)(bu)能相互吻合。故一審法(fa)院對被(bei)訴(su)侵權產(chan)(chan)品(pin)沒(mei)(mei)有“氣(qi)液分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)器(qi)”之(zhi)(zhi)辯解不(bu)(bu)予采信。

康泰藍(lan)公(gong)(gong)司(si)、坑梓自來水公(gong)(gong)司(si)還主張涉(she)案(an)發明(ming)專利(li)技術在申請日(ri)前已經公(gong)(gong)開，一審法院經分析后認定該主張證據不足。

本案還(huan)存在以(yi)下定(ding)性問題：

首先，康(kang)泰藍公司在網站上(shang)宣傳(chuan)其使(shi)用ZL***.4號專利技(ji)術(shu)的行為是否構成針對涉(she)案(an)發明(ming)專利的許諾銷售(shou)侵權？

盡管康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)在其網站公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)產品(pin)“康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)二氧(yang)化氯制備投加工藝簡介”中(zhong)作了如前所述的宣稱，且ZL***.4號專(zhuan)利(li)專(zhuan)利(li)權人已經變更為斯瑞曼公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)，但斯瑞曼公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)在本案中(zhong)請求保護(hu)的是ZL***L 0號專(zhuan)利(li)，從現有(you)證(zheng)據來(lai)看，ZL***.4號專(zhuan)利(li)與(yu)涉(she)案發明(ming)專(zhuan)利(li)并非(fei)完全(quan)一致，斯瑞曼公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)沒(mei)有(you)證(zheng)據證(zheng)明(ming)康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)所宣傳相關產品(pin)技(ji)術(shu)特征落入涉(she)案發明(ming)專(zhuan)利(li)保護(hu)范(fan)圍，故對于斯瑞曼公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)以(yi)康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)網站上述宣傳指(zhi)控康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)藍(lan)公(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)構成針對涉(she)案發明(ming)專(zhuan)利(li)的許諾銷售侵權，不予支(zhi)持(chi)。

其次，本(ben)案康泰藍公(gong)司、坑(keng)梓自來(lai)水公(gong)司的(de)行(xing)(xing)為是否屬(shu)于侵權以及屬(shu)于何(he)種性質(zhi)的(de)侵權行(xing)(xing)為？

根(gen)據現有(you)證(zheng)據以(yi)及一審查明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)事實，涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)于(yu)2006年(nian)7月19日(ri)(ri)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)開(kai)(kai)，于(yu)2009年(nian)1月21日(ri)(ri)授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)告。2008年(nian)10月20日(ri)(ri)，坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)與(yu)(yu)康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)簽訂《購銷合同(tong)》購買被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)，康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)已(yi)于(yu)2008年(nian)12月30日(ri)(ri)就上(shang)(shang)述(shu)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)銷售(shou)(shou)款要(yao)求(qiu)(qiu)(qiu)稅務機關代開(kai)(kai)統一發(fa)(fa)票。上(shang)(shang)述(shu)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)一直被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)，康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)并為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)該(gai)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)的(de)(de)(de)(de)正常運轉提供(gong)維修(xiu)、保(bao)養(yang)等技術支(zhi)持(chi)(chi)。由此可(ke)(ke)見(jian)，康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)可(ke)(ke)以(yi)分(fen)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)開(kai)(kai)之(zhi)后、授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)之(zhi)前(qian)的(de)(de)(de)(de)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)與(yu)(yu)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)之(zhi)后的(de)(de)(de)(de)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)。康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)制造、銷售(shou)(shou)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)的(de)(de)(de)(de)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)主(zhu)要(yao)發(fa)(fa)生(sheng)在(zai)(zai)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)開(kai)(kai)之(zhi)后、授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)告之(zhi)前(qian)。坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)的(de)(de)(de)(de)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)以(yi)及康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)該(gai)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)提供(gong)維修(xiu)、保(bao)養(yang)、技術支(zhi)持(chi)(chi)的(de)(de)(de)(de)幫(bang)助行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)從專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)之(zhi)前(qian)延續(xu)到專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)之(zhi)后。在(zai)(zai)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)之(zhi)前(qian)，康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)實施(shi)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)技術的(de)(de)(de)(de)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)，不屬于(yu)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)。權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)人可(ke)(ke)以(yi)請求(qiu)(qiu)(qiu)支(zhi)付(fu)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)臨時(shi)保(bao)護期使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)費(fei)，但(dan)在(zai)(zai)本案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)中(zhong)，斯(si)(si)瑞曼(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)沒有(you)提出支(zhi)付(fu)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)臨時(shi)保(bao)護期使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)費(fei)的(de)(de)(de)(de)訴(su)訟(song)請求(qiu)(qiu)(qiu)，在(zai)(zai)一審法(fa)院(yuan)已(yi)作適當釋明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)的(de)(de)(de)(de)情況下(xia)，斯(si)(si)瑞曼(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)仍堅持(chi)(chi)原(yuan)請求(qiu)(qiu)(qiu)，沒有(you)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)確在(zai)(zai)本案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)中(zhong)要(yao)求(qiu)(qiu)(qiu)康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)支(zhi)付(fu)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)臨時(shi)保(bao)護期使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)費(fei)，故一審法(fa)院(yuan)在(zai)(zai)本案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)中(zhong)對(dui)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)臨時(shi)保(bao)護期使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)費(fei)不予考慮，斯(si)(si)瑞曼(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)可(ke)(ke)另案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)解(jie)決。但(dan)是(shi)(shi)，一審法(fa)院(yuan)亦注(zhu)意(yi)到，自(zi)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)開(kai)(kai)之(zhi)后、授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)之(zhi)前(qian)、授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)之(zhi)后直至(zhi)本案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)訴(su)訟(song)，坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)一直持(chi)(chi)續(xu)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)，康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)亦為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)該(gai)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)提供(gong)幫(bang)助，該(gai)幫(bang)助行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)既是(shi)(shi)康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)銷售(shou)(shou)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)的(de)(de)(de)(de)延續(xu)，也是(shi)(shi)對(dui)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)的(de)(de)(de)(de)共同(tong)組成部分(fen)，康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)在(zai)(zai)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)后未經許(xu)可(ke)(ke)繼續(xu)實施(shi)該(gai)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)屬于(yu)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)。本案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)斯(si)(si)瑞曼(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)均系(xi)(xi)深圳(zhen)企(qi)業，均系(xi)(xi)與(yu)(yu)水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)處(chu)理設備(bei)制造、銷售(shou)(shou)、使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)相(xiang)關企(qi)業，康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)對(dui)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)應(ying)(ying)有(you)一定了解(jie)，在(zai)(zai)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授(shou)(shou)(shou)(shou)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)后乃至(zhi)于(yu)本案(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)(an)訴(su)訟(song)的(de)(de)(de)(de)整個(ge)過程，康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)仍堅持(chi)(chi)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)，證(zheng)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)其并非善(shan)意(yi)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)人，應(ying)(ying)承擔(dan)相(xiang)應(ying)(ying)的(de)(de)(de)(de)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)賠(pei)償(chang)責任(ren)。考慮坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)消(xiao)毒、凈化處(chu)理涉(she)(she)及社會(hui)(hui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)眾利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)益，停止(zhi)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)的(de)(de)(de)(de)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)將在(zai)(zai)某種程度(du)上(shang)(shang)影響社會(hui)(hui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)益，故一審法(fa)院(yuan)對(dui)于(yu)坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)已(yi)在(zai)(zai)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)中(zhong)的(de)(de)(de)(de)被(bei)(bei)(bei)(bei)訴(su)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)(chan)品(pin)不判令停止(zhi)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)，但(dan)康(kang)(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)(tai)(tai)藍(lan)(lan)(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自(zi)來水(shui)(shui)(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)應(ying)(ying)就該(gai)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)侵(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)行(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)向斯(si)(si)瑞曼(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)(si)作出賠(pei)償(chang)。

廣東省深圳(zhen)市(shi)中級人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)法(fa)院(yuan)一審(shen)認(ren)為(wei)：涉(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利系經(jing)國(guo)家知識產權(quan)(quan)(quan)局依法(fa)授權(quan)(quan)(quan)，且處于(yu)有(you)效(xiao)狀(zhuang)態，應(ying)(ying)受到保(bao)(bao)護。康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)未經(jing)許可(ke)相互配合使用(yong)(yong)(yong)侵犯(fan)(fan)涉(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利權(quan)(quan)(quan)的(de)產品，構(gou)成了對(dui)斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)涉(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利權(quan)(quan)(quan)的(de)侵犯(fan)(fan)，應(ying)(ying)承擔相應(ying)(ying)的(de)侵權(quan)(quan)(quan)賠(pei)(pei)償(chang)責任。斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)要求(qiu)康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)立(li)即停(ting)止制(zhi)造(zao)、銷售侵權(quan)(quan)(quan)產品的(de)請求(qiu)成立(li)，予(yu)以(yi)支持。康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)辯稱涉(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利無效(xiao)，其使用(yong)(yong)(yong)技術(shu)為(wei)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)知技術(shu)，被訴侵權(quan)(quan)(quan)產品沒(mei)有(you)落入專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利保(bao)(bao)護范圍(wei)與本(ben)案(an)(an)事實(shi)不(bu)符，不(bu)予(yu)采信。斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)要求(qiu)康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)賠(pei)(pei)償(chang)其損(sun)(sun)失人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)幣30萬(wan)元(yuan)(yuan)、維(wei)權(quan)(quan)(quan)費用(yong)(yong)(yong)500元(yuan)(yuan)，不(bu)予(yu)全額支持。根據(ju)涉(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利的(de)類(lei)型、侵權(quan)(quan)(quan)行為(wei)情節、斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)維(wei)權(quan)(quan)(quan)所支出(chu)費用(yong)(yong)(yong)等酌定康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)連(lian)帶(dai)賠(pei)(pei)償(chang)斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)經(jing)濟損(sun)(sun)失人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)幣8萬(wan)元(yuan)(yuan)。綜上，依據(ju)《中華(hua)人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)共(gong)和(he)國(guo)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)法(fa)通則》第(di)一百三(san)十條、《中華(hua)人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)共(gong)和(he)國(guo)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利法(fa)》（以(yi)下簡稱專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利法(fa)）第(di)十一條第(di)一款、第(di)五十六條第(di)一款、《最高人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)法(fa)院(yuan)〈關于(yu)審(shen)理專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利糾紛案(an)(an)件適(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)法(fa)律(lv)問題的(de)若干規(gui)定〉》第(di)二(er)十一條、第(di)二(er)十二(er)條、《中華(hua)人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)共(gong)和(he)國(guo)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)事訴訟法(fa)》第(di)六十四條第(di)一款的(de)規(gui)定，廣東省深圳(zhen)市(shi)中級人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)法(fa)院(yuan)于(yu)2010年1月6日作出(chu)（2009）深中法(fa)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)三(san)初字(zi)第(di)94號民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)事判決(jue)：一、康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)立(li)即停(ting)止制(zhi)造(zao)、銷售侵犯(fan)(fan)涉(she)案(an)(an)發(fa)明專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利權(quan)(quan)(quan)的(de)行為(wei)；二(er)、康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)于(yu)判決(jue)生效(xiao)后十日內連(lian)帶(dai)賠(pei)(pei)償(chang)斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)經(jing)濟損(sun)(sun)失人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)幣8萬(wan)元(yuan)(yuan)；三(san)、駁回斯(si)瑞(rui)(rui)曼(man)(man)(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)的(de)其他訴訟請求(qiu)。本(ben)案(an)(an)案(an)(an)件受理費人(ren)民(min)(min)(min)(min)(min)幣5800元(yuan)(yuan)，證據(ju)保(bao)(bao)全費30元(yuan)(yuan)，由(you)康(kang)(kang)泰(tai)(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)、坑(keng)梓(zi)(zi)自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)共(gong)同(tong)負擔。

康泰藍公司、坑梓自來水公司均不服一審判決，向廣東省高級人民法院提起上訴。

廣東省高級(ji)人民法(fa)院經審查(cha)，一審法(fa)院查(cha)明(ming)的(de)事實屬實，予以確認。

 廣東省高級人民法院二審(shen)認為，本案爭議焦點為，程序問題；被訴侵(qin)權產品是否(fou)落(luo)入(ru)涉案發(fa)明專利權利要求1的保護(hu)范圍；坑梓自來水(shui)公(gong)司是否(fou)善意使用。

（一）關于程序(xu)的問題

《中(zhong)華人民共(gong)(gong)和國(guo)民事(shi)訴(su)訟(song)法》第一(yi)百(bai)二十六條規(gui)(gui)定，原告(gao)增加(jia)訴(su)訟(song)請(qing)求(qiu)，被(bei)告(gao)提(ti)(ti)出(chu)反(fan)訴(su)，第三人提(ti)(ti)出(chu)與(yu)本案有(you)關的(de)訴(su)訟(song)請(qing)求(qiu)，可以合并(bing)審理。《最高人民法院關于適用〈中(zhong)華人民共(gong)(gong)和國(guo)民事(shi)訴(su)訟(song)法〉若干問(wen)題的(de)意見》第一(yi)百(bai)五(wu)十六條規(gui)(gui)定，在案件(jian)受理后，法庭(ting)辯論結束前，原告(gao)增加(jia)訴(su)訟(song)請(qing)求(qiu)，被(bei)告(gao)提(ti)(ti)出(chu)反(fan)訴(su)，第三人提(ti)(ti)出(chu)與(yu)本案有(you)關的(de)訴(su)訟(song)請(qing)求(qiu)，可以合并(bing)審理的(de)，人民法院應當合并(bing)審理。根據(ju)上述法律及司法解釋的(de)規(gui)(gui)定，斯(si)瑞曼公(gong)司在一(yi)審開庭(ting)時提(ti)(ti)出(chu)增加(jia)判令康(kang)泰藍公(gong)司立即(ji)停止(zhi)侵(qin)犯涉案發明專利權的(de)許諾(nuo)銷售行(xing)為(wei)的(de)訴(su)訟(song)請(qing)求(qiu)，一(yi)審法院當庭(ting)準許并(bing)無不當。

（二）關于(yu)被訴侵權(quan)產品是(shi)否落入涉案發明專利權(quan)利要(yao)求1的保護(hu)范圍的問(wen)題

康泰藍公司(si)上訴認(ren)為，被訴侵權產(chan)品的(de)(de)反應及氣液分(fen)離(li)過程主要發(fa)(fa)生(sheng)在反應器(qi)(qi)中(zhong)，無需再(zai)設置氣液分(fen)離(li)器(qi)(qi)，其(qi)并未(wei)實(shi)施涉(she)案(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)專利中(zhong)的(de)(de)氣液分(fen)離(li)器(qi)(qi)、文氏管加料器(qi)(qi)，管線的(de)(de)連接方式(shi)也不同，一審判(pan)決(jue)將“三通管道”等同于“氣液分(fen)離(li)器(qi)(qi)”缺乏依據。

根據(ju)一(yi)審法院(yuan)對康泰藍(lan)公(gong)司(si)生產(chan)、銷(xiao)售的(de)(de)被(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)品(pin)進(jin)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)現場勘察、比對的(de)(de)情況來(lai)看，被(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)品(pin)為一(yi)種(zhong)制備(bei)高純(chun)度二氧(yang)化(hua)氯(lv)的(de)(de)設備(bei)，具有兩個液(ye)(ye)(ye)體(ti)計量槽、兩個計量泵、兩個加(jia)熱器(qi)、第(di)一(yi)空(kong)(kong)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)進(jin)口(kou)，第(di)一(yi)空(kong)(kong)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)進(jin)口(kou)與“噴(pen)射反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)器(qi)”進(jin)口(kou)端相(xiang)連(lian)，“噴(pen)射反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)器(qi)”之后連(lian)接(jie)有反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)器(qi)（發(fa)(fa)(fa)生器(qi)）。將(jiang)被(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)品(pin)與涉案(an)發(fa)(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利進(jin)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)比較，可知兩者均需(xu)要(yao)通過(guo)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)的(de)(de)方(fang)法從反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)后的(de)(de)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)混(hun)合(he)物(wu)(wu)中(zhong)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)出(chu)高純(chun)度的(de)(de)二氧(yang)化(hua)氯(lv)，以達到(dao)對飲用水的(de)(de)消毒凈化(hua)，確保水質達標的(de)(de)目的(de)(de)。被(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)品(pin)系將(jiang)原料(liao)在(zai)“噴(pen)射反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)器(qi)”中(zhong)進(jin)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)后，傳(chuan)送(song)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)混(hun)合(he)物(wu)(wu)至反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)器(qi)，對未充分(fen)(fen)反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)的(de)(de)原料(liao)繼續(xu)進(jin)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)，同(tong)時將(jiang)二氧(yang)化(hua)氯(lv)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)體(ti)與殘液(ye)(ye)(ye)相(xiang)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)。涉案(an)發(fa)(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)利要(yao)求1則是(shi)將(jiang)原料(liao)在(zai)文氏(shi)管(guan)加(jia)料(liao)器(qi)進(jin)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)，再(zai)將(jiang)反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)后的(de)(de)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)混(hun)合(he)物(wu)(wu)通過(guo)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)器(qi)進(jin)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)，從而得到(dao)消毒所需(xu)的(de)(de)二氧(yang)化(hua)氯(lv)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)體(ti)。也(ye)就是(shi)說(shuo)，盡管(guan)被(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)品(pin)沒(mei)有設置單(dan)獨的(de)(de)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)器(qi)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)混(hun)合(he)物(wu)(wu)，但(dan)根據(ju)其(qi)產(chan)品(pin)的(de)(de)結構、連(lian)接(jie)關(guan)系和(he)工作原理(li)，其(qi)在(zai)反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)器(qi)中(zhong)實(shi)現的(de)(de)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)與涉案(an)發(fa)(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利單(dan)獨設置氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)器(qi)進(jin)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)，系以基(ji)本(ben)相(xiang)同(tong)的(de)(de)手段，實(shi)現基(ji)本(ben)相(xiang)同(tong)的(de)(de)功能，達到(dao)基(ji)本(ben)相(xiang)同(tong)的(de)(de)效(xiao)果，并(bing)且本(ben)領域的(de)(de)普通技(ji)術(shu)人員無(wu)需(xu)經過(guo)創造性勞動就能夠聯想到(dao)的(de)(de)特(te)征。至于反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)器(qi)還(huan)具備(bei)氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)器(qi)所不(bu)備(bei)的(de)(de)殘余物(wu)(wu)料(liao)二次反(fan)(fan)應(ying)(ying)(ying)功能，則屬于被(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)品(pin)多于涉案(an)發(fa)(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利的(de)(de)技(ji)術(shu)特(te)征，對于判定是(shi)否(fou)構成侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)不(bu)產(chan)生影響。因此，康泰藍(lan)公(gong)司(si)以被(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產(chan)品(pin)不(bu)具備(bei)本(ben)專(zhuan)利氣(qi)(qi)(qi)(qi)液(ye)(ye)(ye)分(fen)(fen)離(li)(li)器(qi)的(de)(de)技(ji)術(shu)特(te)征為由，認為其(qi)不(bu)侵(qin)犯涉案(an)發(fa)(fa)(fa)明專(zhuan)利權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)不(bu)成立，不(bu)予支(zhi)持。

（三(san)）關于坑(keng)梓自來水公司是(shi)否善意使(shi)用的問(wen)題

專利法（2000年修改）第六十三條第二款規定，為生產經營目的使用或者銷售不知道是未經專利權人許可而制造并售出的專利產品或者依照專利方法直接獲得的產品，能證明其產品合法來源的，不承擔賠償責任。坑梓自來水公司與斯瑞曼公司均為從事水處理行業的企業法人，又同處同一行政區域即深圳市內，理應對同一區域、行業的技術、設備有所知曉。坑梓自(zi)來水公司(si)(si)被訴(su)至一審法院后(hou)，已知道(dao)其(qi)使用(yong)的產品(pin)可能侵(qin)犯(fan)涉案發明專利權(quan)，也未停止(zhi)使用(yong)被訴(su)侵(qin)權(quan)產品(pin)，故坑梓自(zi)來水公司(si)(si)認為其(qi)通過合(he)法的進貨(huo)渠道(dao)、正常(chang)的買賣(mai)合(he)同和合(he)理的價格從康泰藍公司(si)(si)購買被訴(su)侵(qin)權(quan)產品(pin)，構(gou)成合(he)法來源(yuan)抗(kang)辯的理由不成立，不予支持。

綜上(shang)，廣東省(sheng)高(gao)級人(ren)民法(fa)院于2010年11月15日作出（2010）粵高(gao)法(fa)民三終字第444號民事判(pan)決(jue)：駁回上(shang)訴，維持(chi)原(yuan)判(pan)。本案(an)二審案(an)件(jian)受理費(fei)5800元，由康泰(tai)藍公司(si)、坑梓自來(lai)水公司(si)各負擔2900元。

坑(keng)梓自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)申請再(zai)審(shen)(shen)稱：1.一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)、二審(shen)(shen)判決認(ren)定(ding)事實的(de)主(zhu)要證據(ju)不(bu)(bu)足(zu)，且有新(xin)的(de)證據(ju)足(zu)以推翻(fan)原判決。2007年11月27日，康泰藍(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)與項耀明(ming)、焦(jiao)立國(guo)就ZL***.4號專(zhuan)(zhuan)利簽訂《專(zhuan)(zhuan)利技術轉讓合同》，取得該(gai)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利的(de)使用(yong)(yong)權(quan)(quan)。該(gai)新(xin)的(de)證據(ju)表明(ming)坑(keng)梓自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)購買并使用(yong)(yong)康泰藍(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)合法(fa)的(de)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利產品(pin)(pin)不(bu)(bu)構(gou)成侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)。2.根(gen)據(ju)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利法(fa)第(di)(di)六十(shi)三條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)二款規(gui)定(ding)，坑(keng)梓自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)購買和使用(yong)(yong)被訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)產品(pin)(pin)時(shi)，支(zhi)付了合理對價，為善意使用(yong)(yong)人(ren)(ren)，在(zai)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)審(shen)(shen)判決后主(zhu)動停止(zhi)了對被訴(su)(su)侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)產品(pin)(pin)的(de)使用(yong)(yong)，不(bu)(bu)構(gou)成侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)。3.—、二審(shen)(shen)法(fa)院(yuan)(yuan)均認(ren)定(ding)ZL***.4號專(zhuan)(zhuan)利與涉(she)案發明(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利不(bu)(bu)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)致(zhi)，坑(keng)梓自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)使用(yong)(yong)的(de)是(shi)康泰藍(lan)(lan)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)根(gen)據(ju)ZL***.4號專(zhuan)(zhuan)利制造的(de)產品(pin)(pin)，對涉(she)案發明(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利不(bu)(bu)構(gou)成侵(qin)權(quan)(quan)。4.一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)審(shen)(shen)法(fa)院(yuan)(yuan)違反《最高(gao)人(ren)(ren)民法(fa)院(yuan)(yuan)關于(yu)民事訴(su)(su)訟證據(ju)的(de)若干規(gui)定(ding)》第(di)(di)三十(shi)四條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)三款規(gui)定(ding)，允(yun)許斯(si)瑞曼公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)當(dang)(dang)庭(ting)增(zeng)加訴(su)(su)訟請求(qiu)。二審(shen)(shen)法(fa)院(yuan)(yuan)適(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)在(zai)后生效的(de)《中(zhong)華(hua)人(ren)(ren)民共(gong)和國(guo)民事訴(su)(su)訟法(fa)》第(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)百(bai)二十(shi)六條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)和《最高(gao)人(ren)(ren)民法(fa)院(yuan)(yuan)關于(yu)適(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)〈中(zhong)華(hua)人(ren)(ren)民共(gong)和國(guo)民事訴(su)(su)訟法(fa)〉若干問題的(de)意見》第(di)(di)156條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)規(gui)定(ding)，認(ren)定(ding)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)審(shen)(shen)法(fa)院(yuan)(yuan)當(dang)(dang)庭(ting)準(zhun)許并無不(bu)(bu)當(dang)(dang)，屬于(yu)適(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)法(fa)律不(bu)(bu)當(dang)(dang)。坑(keng)梓自(zi)來(lai)水(shui)(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)依據(ju)《中(zhong)華(hua)人(ren)(ren)民共(gong)和國(guo)民事訴(su)(su)訟法(fa)》第(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)百(bai)七(qi)十(shi)九條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款第(di)(di)（一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)）項、第(di)(di)（六）項的(de)規(gui)定(ding)申請再(zai)審(shen)(shen)。

被(bei)申(shen)請人斯瑞(rui)曼(man)公司辯稱(cheng)：1.新的(de)證據(ju)《專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)技術(shu)(shu)轉(zhuan)讓合同(tong)》不(bu)具有(you)真實性、合法性。康泰藍(lan)公司成(cheng)立于(yu)(yu)2007年12月24日，2007年11月27日尚不(bu)具有(you)民事(shi)主體資格，無(wu)法簽訂《專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)技術(shu)(shu)轉(zhuan)讓合同(tong)》，且無(wu)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)轉(zhuan)讓登記(ji)文件證明該專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)轉(zhuan)讓生效(xiao)。《專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)技術(shu)(shu)轉(zhuan)讓合同(tong)》已經(jing)被(bei)云(yun)南省(sheng)高級人民法院（2008）云(yun)高民三初(chu)字第(di)101號(hao)(hao)民事(shi)判決認定(ding)為(wei)無(wu)效(xiao)。2.坑(keng)梓自(zi)來(lai)水公司認為(wei)自(zi)己使(shi)用(yong)(yong)的(de)是ZL***.4號(hao)(hao)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)，從而不(bu)侵(qin)(qin)犯(fan)涉案(an)發明專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)的(de)抗(kang)辯邏輯(ji)錯(cuo)誤。3.關于(yu)(yu)坑(keng)梓自(zi)來(lai)水公司在涉案(an)發明專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)臨時保護(hu)期內(nei)向(xiang)康泰藍(lan)公司購(gou)買被(bei)訴侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)產品后(hou)，其(qi)后(hou)續使(shi)用(yong)(yong)包括(kuo)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)后(hou)的(de)使(shi)用(yong)(yong)行(xing)為(wei)是否構成(cheng)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)的(de)問題。專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法第(di)十一(yi)條第(di)一(yi)款規定(ding)了(le)發明和實用(yong)(yong)新型(xing)專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)人享有(you)的(de)禁用(yong)(yong)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)，該禁用(yong)(yong)權(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)(quan)針對制(zhi)造、使(shi)用(yong)(yong)、許(xu)諾銷(xiao)(xiao)售、銷(xiao)(xiao)售、進口五種行(xing)為(wei)。

五種(zhong)(zhong)禁(jin)止實施(shi)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)相(xiang)(xiang)互獨立，分別構成(cheng)單(dan)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)類型的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)。此(ci)(ci)外(wai)，專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)對(dui)(dui)(dui)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)限(xian)制主要(yao)體(ti)現在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)“除(chu)本法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)另(ling)有規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)以(yi)外(wai)”的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)及(ji)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)六(liu)十(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)(san)(san)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)。其(qi)(qi)中，專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)“本法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)另(ling)有規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)”系(xi)指(zhi)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)四(si)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)和(he)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)四(si)十(shi)(shi)(shi)八條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)至第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)五十(shi)(shi)(shi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)。本案(an)(an)中，坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)涉案(an)(an)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授權(quan)(quan)后(hou)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)被(bei)(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)，顯(xian)(xian)然已(yi)經滿足專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)要(yao)件(jian)，不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)屬(shu)(shu)于(yu)(yu)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)四(si)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)和(he)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)四(si)十(shi)(shi)(shi)八條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)至第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)五十(shi)(shi)(shi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)侵(qin)(qin)犯(fan)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)例(li)外(wai)，也(ye)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)屬(shu)(shu)于(yu)(yu)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)六(liu)十(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)(san)(san)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)視為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)侵(qin)(qin)犯(fan)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)任(ren)(ren)(ren)何一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)項情形，應(ying)當(dang)構成(cheng)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)。此(ci)(ci)外(wai)，坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)并(bing)(bing)(bing)未提供(gong)其(qi)(qi)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)知道(dao)所(suo)(suo)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)設備是(shi)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)相(xiang)(xiang)關證明(ming)(ming)，也(ye)沒有證明(ming)(ming)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)審判決后(hou)即(ji)停止使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)被(bei)(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)，且(qie)即(ji)使(shi)(shi)提交也(ye)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)能對(dui)(dui)(dui)之前的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)免(mian)責(ze)(ze)(ze)(ze)；深圳市水(shui)務局城市供(gong)水(shui)水(shui)質(zhi)(zhi)報告顯(xian)(xian)示(shi)坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)仍使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)二(er)氧(yang)化氯消毒設備；坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)購(gou)(gou)(gou)買被(bei)(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)時(shi)(shi)，康(kang)泰(tai)藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)尚未取得(de)(de)(de)衛生許(xu)可(ke)批件(jian)，依(yi)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)得(de)(de)(de)銷售，坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)購(gou)(gou)(gou)買并(bing)(bing)(bing)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)無批準文(wen)件(jian)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)被(bei)(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)，主觀上(shang)(shang)明(ming)(ming)顯(xian)(xian)存(cun)在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)惡意(yi)。因此(ci)(ci)，坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)符(fu)合專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)六(liu)十(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)(san)(san)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)二(er)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)“不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)知道(dao)”要(yao)件(jian)，不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)能免(mian)除(chu)賠(pei)償責(ze)(ze)(ze)(ze)任(ren)(ren)(ren)。4.關于(yu)(yu)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)(san)(san)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)本案(an)(an)中的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)適用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)問題。斯瑞(rui)曼(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)本案(an)(an)中選擇追究坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)承擔(dan)授權(quan)(quan)后(hou)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)責(ze)(ze)(ze)(ze)任(ren)(ren)(ren)，而(er)未請(qing)求(qiu)坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)支付(fu)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)臨(lin)(lin)時(shi)(shi)保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)期(qi)(qi)(qi)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)費(fei)，是(shi)對(dui)(dui)(dui)自身合法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)權(quan)(quan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)適當(dang)處(chu)置，應(ying)當(dang)受到(dao)(dao)(dao)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)律保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)。斯瑞(rui)曼(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)本案(an)(an)中并(bing)(bing)(bing)未請(qing)求(qiu)給(gei)付(fu)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)臨(lin)(lin)時(shi)(shi)保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)期(qi)(qi)(qi)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)費(fei)，因此(ci)(ci)本案(an)(an)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)適用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)(san)(san)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)。專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)對(dui)(dui)(dui)臨(lin)(lin)時(shi)(shi)保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)期(qi)(qi)(qi)內實施(shi)其(qi)(qi)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)雖然沒有禁(jin)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)權(quan)(quan)，但過了(le)臨(lin)(lin)時(shi)(shi)保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)期(qi)(qi)(qi)進入(ru)到(dao)(dao)(dao)授權(quan)(quan)之后(hou)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)也(ye)自當(dang)接受專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)約束。若以(yi)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)(san)(san)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)由(you)認定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)被(bei)(bei)訴(su)(su)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)構成(cheng)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)，將(jiang)(jiang)導致(zhi)以(yi)下后(hou)果：其(qi)(qi)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)、專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)文(wen)將(jiang)(jiang)被(bei)(bei)改寫，因為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)沒有任(ren)(ren)(ren)何對(dui)(dui)(dui)授權(quan)(quan)后(hou)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)設置一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)個只(zhi)要(yao)該(gai)(gai)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)開始(shi)于(yu)(yu)臨(lin)(lin)時(shi)(shi)保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)期(qi)(qi)(qi)即(ji)可(ke)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)承擔(dan)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)責(ze)(ze)(ze)(ze)任(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)例(li)外(wai)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)。其(qi)(qi)二(er)、專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)(san)(san)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)將(jiang)(jiang)成(cheng)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)責(ze)(ze)(ze)(ze)任(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)豁免(mian)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)，專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)形同(tong)虛設。如(ru)果被(bei)(bei)訴(su)(su)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)人(ren)(ren)都以(yi)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)(san)(san)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)由(you)，主張其(qi)(qi)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)開始(shi)于(yu)(yu)臨(lin)(lin)時(shi)(shi)保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)期(qi)(qi)(qi)從而(er)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)構成(cheng)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)，那么將(jiang)(jiang)極易(yi)出現這(zhe)樣(yang)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)種(zhong)(zhong)情形：在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)申(shen)請(qing)人(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)申(shen)請(qing)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)開后(hou)，甲(jia)即(ji)按該(gai)(gai)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)申(shen)請(qing)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)記載開始(shi)大量制造、銷售相(xiang)(xiang)應(ying)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)，乙從甲(jia)處(chu)購(gou)(gou)(gou)買該(gai)(gai)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)并(bing)(bing)(bing)開始(shi)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)，申(shen)請(qing)人(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)市場(chang)被(bei)(bei)搶占。在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授權(quan)(quan)后(hou)，專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)只(zhi)能向甲(jia)、乙主張臨(lin)(lin)時(shi)(shi)保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)期(qi)(qi)(qi)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)合理使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)費(fei)，在(zai)(zai)(zai)(zai)費(fei)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)金額上(shang)(shang)顯(xian)(xian)然遠低于(yu)(yu)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)賠(pei)償金，其(qi)(qi)投入(ru)到(dao)(dao)(dao)發(fa)(fa)明(ming)(ming)創造的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)成(cheng)本不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)能得(de)(de)(de)到(dao)(dao)(dao)有效(xiao)回收。而(er)由(you)于(yu)(yu)乙的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)繼續(xu)(xu)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)是(shi)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)，專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)無權(quan)(quan)禁(jin)止，也(ye)無法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)與(yu)(yu)其(qi)(qi)簽(qian)訂(ding)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)實施(shi)許(xu)可(ke)合同(tong)，失(shi)去的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)市場(chang)也(ye)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)能重新尋(xun)回。這(zhe)種(zhong)(zhong)情形可(ke)以(yi)被(bei)(bei)大量、反復、沒有任(ren)(ren)(ren)何限(xian)制地(di)復制，專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)合法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)權(quan)(quan)益(yi)無疑會遭受極大損(sun)害。如(ru)此(ci)(ci)，專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)對(dui)(dui)(dui)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)保(bao)(bao)(bao)護(hu)(hu)(hu)即(ji)成(cheng)空談。至于(yu)(yu)坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)所(suo)(suo)稱如(ru)果持續(xu)(xu)到(dao)(dao)(dao)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)授權(quan)(quan)以(yi)后(hou)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)行(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)構成(cheng)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)，將(jiang)(jiang)對(dui)(dui)(dui)其(qi)(qi)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)平，完(wan)全系(xi)其(qi)(qi)對(dui)(dui)(dui)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)片面理解(jie)。5.一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)、二(er)審判決坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)承擔(dan)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)責(ze)(ze)(ze)(ze)任(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)基礎(chu)是(shi)其(qi)(qi)未經專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)許(xu)可(ke)，為(wei)(wei)(wei)(wei)生產(chan)(chan)經營目的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)，相(xiang)(xiang)應(ying)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)賠(pei)償系(xi)繼續(xu)(xu)使(shi)(shi)用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)被(bei)(bei)訴(su)(su)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)(quan)產(chan)(chan)品(pin)(pin)所(suo)(suo)支付(fu)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)對(dui)(dui)(dui)價，具有專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)(li)許(xu)可(ke)費(fei)性質(zhi)(zhi)。6.—審法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)院(yuan)允(yun)許(xu)斯瑞(rui)曼(man)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)當(dang)庭增加訴(su)(su)訟(song)請(qing)求(qiu)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)構成(cheng)程(cheng)序違(wei)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)，且(qie)該(gai)(gai)訴(su)(su)訟(song)請(qing)求(qiu)并(bing)(bing)(bing)未得(de)(de)(de)到(dao)(dao)(dao)支持。《最(zui)高人(ren)(ren)民(min)(min)(min)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)院(yuan)關于(yu)(yu)適用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)〈中華人(ren)(ren)民(min)(min)(min)共和(he)國民(min)(min)(min)事訴(su)(su)訟(song)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)〉若干問題的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)意(yi)見》第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)156條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)是(shi)對(dui)(dui)(dui)《中華人(ren)(ren)民(min)(min)(min)共和(he)國民(min)(min)(min)事訴(su)(su)訟(song)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)》第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)一(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)(yi)百二(er)十(shi)(shi)(shi)六(liu)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)具體(ti)補充(chong)與(yu)(yu)解(jie)釋，《最(zui)高人(ren)(ren)民(min)(min)(min)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)院(yuan)關于(yu)(yu)民(min)(min)(min)事訴(su)(su)訟(song)證據的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)若干規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)》第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)三(san)(san)(san)十(shi)(shi)(shi)四(si)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)第(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)(di)三(san)(san)(san)款(kuan)(kuan)(kuan)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)與(yu)(yu)該(gai)(gai)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)沖突時(shi)(shi)，應(ying)適用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)該(gai)(gai)條(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)(tiao)規(gui)(gui)(gui)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)。綜上(shang)(shang)所(suo)(suo)述，坑(keng)(keng)(keng)梓(zi)(zi)(zi)自來(lai)(lai)水(shui)公(gong)(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)的(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)(de)申(shen)請(qing)再審理由(you)不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)成(cheng)立，二(er)審判決適用(yong)(yong)(yong)(yong)法(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)(fa)律并(bing)(bing)(bing)無不(bu)(bu)(bu)(bu)當(dang)，應(ying)予維持。

被申請人(ren)(ren)康泰藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)辯稱：康泰藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)在(zai)(zai)籌(chou)備時(shi)(shi)，當時(shi)(shi)的法定代(dai)表(biao)人(ren)(ren)鄭(zheng)素(su)華代(dai)表(biao)公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)與(yu)ZL***.4號專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)的權(quan)(quan)利(li)(li)(li)人(ren)(ren)項耀明、焦立(li)國簽訂了(le)《專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)技術轉讓(rang)合(he)同》，并支付了(le)17萬元轉讓(rang)價款。由(you)于康泰藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)管理及負責人(ren)(ren)變更等(deng)原(yuan)因，原(yuan)審中未能提供該《專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)技術轉讓(rang)合(he)同》。二(er)審結束后，公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)股(gu)東在(zai)(zai)整理公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)材料時(shi)(shi)偶(ou)然在(zai)(zai)鄭(zheng)素(su)華手(shou)里發(fa)現了(le)該《專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)技術轉讓(rang)合(he)同》。在(zai)(zai)ZL***.4號專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)權(quan)(quan)人(ren)(ren)變更之前，康泰藍公(gong)(gong)(gong)司(si)(si)(si)(si)合(he)法擁有該專(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)(li)(li)的使用(yong)權(quan)(quan)，不存在(zai)(zai)任何侵權(quan)(quan)行為。

本院再審查明，雙方當事人對一、二審法院查明的涉案發明專利的公開日、授權公告日和被訴侵權產品的銷售時間的事實沒有提出異議，本院對該事實予以確認。另查明，一審判決載明，經一審法院釋(shi)明(ming)，斯瑞曼公司(si)在本案中沒有提出支付發(fa)明(ming)專(zhuan)利臨(lin)時保(bao)護期使用費(fei)(fei)的訴訟請求，故本案對發(fa)明(ming)專(zhuan)利臨(lin)時保(bao)護期使用費(fei)(fei)不(bu)予(yu)考慮。本院再審開(kai)庭時，斯瑞曼公司(si)對此予(yu)以認(ren)可。

本院再審認為：斯(si)瑞曼公(gong)司在(zai)(zai)本案(an)(an)中沒有提出支付發明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)臨時(shi)保(bao)護(hu)期使用費的訴(su)訟請求(qiu)，因此，本案(an)(an)的主要爭議焦點在(zai)(zai)于，坑梓自來(lai)(lai)水公(gong)司在(zai)(zai)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)發明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)授權后使用其在(zai)(zai)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)發明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)臨時(shi)保(bao)護(hu)期內向康泰藍(lan)公(gong)司購買的被訴(su)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)侵(qin)(qin)權產(chan)品是否侵(qin)(qin)犯(fan)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)發明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)權，康泰藍(lan)公(gong)司在(zai)(zai)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)發明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)授權后為坑梓自來(lai)(lai)水公(gong)司使用被訴(su)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)侵(qin)(qin)權產(chan)品提供售(shou)后服務是否侵(qin)(qin)犯(fan)涉(she)(she)案(an)(an)發明(ming)(ming)專(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)(zhuan)利(li)權。

對于侵犯專利權行為的認定，應當全面綜合考慮專利法的相關規定。根據本案被訴侵權行為時間，本案應當適用2000年修改的專利法。專利法第十一條第一款規定：“發明和實用新型專利權被授予后，除本法另有規定的以外，任何單位或者個人未經專利權人許可，都不得實施其專利，即不得為生產經營目的制造、使用、許諾銷售、銷售、進口其專利產品，或者使用其專利方法以及使用、許諾銷售、銷售、進口依照該專利方法直接獲得的產品。”第十三條規定：“發(fa)明專利申(shen)請公布(bu)后，申(shen)請人(ren)(ren)可以要求(qiu)實施其發(fa)明的(de)單位或者個人(ren)(ren)支付適(shi)當的(de)費用。”第六十二條規定：“侵犯專利權的訴訟時效為二年，自專利權人或者利害關系人得知或者應當得知侵權行為之日起計算。發明專利申請公布后至專利權授予前使用該發明未支付適當使用費的，專利權人要求支付使用費的訴訟時效為二年，自專利權人得知或者應當得知他人使用其發明之日起計算，但是，專利權人于專利權授予之日前即已得知或者應當得知的，自專利權授予之日起計算。”綜合考慮上述規定，專利法雖然規定了申請人可以要求在發明專利申請公布后至專利權授予之前（即專利臨時保護期內》實施其發明的單位或者個人支付適當的費用，即享有請求給付發明專利臨時保護期使用費的權利，但(dan)對于專(zhuan)利臨(lin)時保護期內(nei)實施其發明的(de)行為并(bing)不享有請求停止(zhi)實施的(de)權利。因此，在發明專利(li)臨時(shi)保護(hu)期(qi)內實施相關發明的(de)，不屬(shu)于專利(li)法禁止的(de)行為。在專利(li)臨時(shi)保護(hu)期(qi)內制造、銷(xiao)售、進(jin)口(kou)被(bei)訴專利(li)侵權(quan)產品(pin)不為專利(li)法禁止的(de)情況下，其后(hou)續(xu)的(de)使用、許諾(nuo)銷(xiao)售、銷(xiao)售該產品(pin)的(de)行為，即使未(wei)經專利(li)權(quan)人許可，也應(ying)當得(de)到(dao)允許。也就(jiu)是說，專利(li)權人(ren)無權禁止他人(ren)對(dui)專利(li)臨時保護期內制造(zao)、銷售、進口的被訴專利(li)侵權產品(pin)的后續使用、許諾銷售、銷售。當(dang)然，這并不否定專利權(quan)人根據(ju)專利法第十三條(tiao)規定行使(shi)要求實(shi)施其發明者支付(fu)適當(dang)費用的(de)權(quan)利。對于(yu)在專利臨時保護期內制造、銷售、進(jin)口的(de)被訴專利侵權(quan)產(chan)品，在銷售者(zhe)、使用者(zhe)提供了合法來源的(de)情況(kuang)下，銷售者(zhe)、使用者(zhe)不(bu)應承擔支付(fu)適當費用的(de)責任。這里的“合法來源”是指相關產品是通過正當、合法的商業渠道獲得的，并不必然要求考慮銷(xiao)售(shou)者(zhe)或(huo)者(zhe)供應者(zhe)在(zai)提供相關產品時是否符合相關行政管理規定。

本案中，康泰藍公司銷售被訴專利侵權產品是在涉案發明專利臨時保護期內，該行為即使是在未取得衛生許可批件而不得銷售的情況下，也不為專利法所禁止。在此情況下，后續的坑梓自來水公司使用所購買的被訴專利侵權產品的行為也應當得到允許。因此，坑梓自來水公司后續的使用行為不侵犯涉案發明專利權。同理，康泰藍公司在涉案發明(ming)專利(li)授權(quan)后為坑梓自來(lai)水(shui)公司使用被訴專利(li)侵(qin)(qin)權(quan)產(chan)品提供售后服務也(ye)不侵(qin)(qin)犯涉案發明(ming)專利(li)權(quan)。

鑒于本院已經認定坑梓(zi)自(zi)來(lai)水公司(si)(si)的后(hou)續使用(yong)行為(wei)不(bu)(bu)構成侵權(quan)，對(dui)于坑梓(zi)自(zi)來(lai)水公司(si)(si)以新(xin)的證據《專(zhuan)利(li)技術轉讓(rang)合同》為(wei)由主張被訴專(zhuan)利(li)侵權(quan)產品(pin)(pin)是使用(yong)ZL***.4號專(zhuan)利(li)生產的合法產品(pin)(pin)，不(bu)(bu)侵犯涉案發明專(zhuan)利(li)權(quan)，不(bu)(bu)再評論。

根(gen)據《中華人(ren)民(min)共和屆民(min)事訴(su)(su)訟法(fa)(fa)》第(di)一百(bai)二十六條和《最高人(ren)民(min)法(fa)(fa)院關于適用(yong)(yong)〈中華人(ren)民(min)共和國民(min)事訴(su)(su)訟法(fa)(fa)〉若干問題的意見》第(di)156條規定，一審法(fa)(fa)院當庭允許斯瑞曼公司在開(kai)庭中增加訴(su)(su)訟請求并不(bu)違反法(fa)(fa)定程(cheng)序(xu)，二審法(fa)(fa)院對此的認定不(bu)存(cun)在法(fa)(fa)律適用(yong)(yong)錯誤。

綜上，依(yi)照《中華人(ren)民共(gong)和(he)國(guo)民事訴訟法》第(di)(di)一百八十六(liu)條(tiao)第(di)(di)一款(kuan)、第(di)(di)一百五(wu)十三(san)條(tiao)第(di)(di)一款(kuan)第(di)(di)（二）項以及《中華人(ren)民共(gong)和(he)國(guo)專(zhuan)利法》第(di)(di)十一條(tiao)第(di)(di)一款(kuan)、第(di)(di)十三(san)條(tiao)、第(di)(di)六(liu)十二條(tiao)的規(gui)定，判決如下：

一(yi)、撤銷廣(guang)東(dong)省高級人民(min)(min)法(fa)院（2010）粵高法(fa)民(min)(min)三(san)終字(zi)第444號民(min)(min)事判決和深圳(zhen)市(shi)中級人民(min)(min)法(fa)院（2009）深中法(fa)民(min)(min)三(san)初字(zi)第94號民(min)(min)事判決。

二、駁回深圳(zhen)市斯瑞曼(man)精細化工有限公司(si)的(de)訴訟(song)請(qing)求(qiu)。

本案(an)一(yi)審(shen)案(an)件受理費(fei)5800元(yuan)，證據保(bao)全(quan)費(fei)30元(yuan)，二審(shen)案(an)件受理費(fei)5800元(yuan)，由深圳市斯(si)瑞(rui)曼(man)精細(xi)化工有(you)限公(gong)司負(fu)擔。

本判決為終審(shen)判決。